Dr. Karina King introduces the webinar, highlighting that pneumonia remains the leading cause of infectious mortality in children under five, a problem exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. She discusses issues like inequitable access to oxygen, underfunding for pneumonia research (especially for diagnostics and health systems), and the challenges of accurate diagnosis in low-resource settings, often relying on manual breath counts.
Taylor Salisbury from R4D presents findings from a study in Tanzania on correct diagnosis of childhood pneumonia. The study used direct observation of healthcare providers and portable lung ultrasound as a reference standard. Key findings reveal high rates of misdiagnosis, with only 18% of pneumonia cases (confirmed by ultrasound) being correctly diagnosed by providers. There's a significant 'know-do' gap, where providers know the IMCI protocol but often don't perform the necessary steps.
Lopa Ray Swati from RTI International presents findings from a study in rural Uttar Pradesh, India, focusing on the 'know-can' gap among frontline health workers (ASHA and RMP). The study found that while some workers had knowledge of pneumonia signs, their practical skills in identifying these signs were much lower. Training focused solely on knowledge did not translate to improved diagnostic skills, highlighting the need for skill-based interventions.
Dr. Manili Amiri, a pediatrician from Tanzania, discusses reasons for the 'know-can-do' gap from a clinician's perspective. She emphasizes the importance of pre-service training, adequate clinical exposure, supportive supervision, quality audits, job aids, and continuous professional development. She suggests prioritizing teaching sessions, clinical simulations, mentorship, and telemedicine for improving skills.
Dr. Anthuli Kappalogway, Director of Health Services in Tanzania, explains how the R4D study findings are informing government strategy. Initiatives include stakeholder meetings, seeking assistance from the Pediatric Association of Tanzania for supportive supervision and mentorship, considering outreach and mobile services due to the country's size, and investing in telemedicine to connect frontline workers with higher-level expertise. He notes that the knowledge gap widens at lower levels of the health system.
Dr. Sumita Gosh, Additional Commissioner of Child Health in India, discusses India's large-scale program for childhood pneumonia. She identifies gaps from community treatment-seeking behavior to provider practice. Initiatives include training peripheral workers (ASHAs) for early diagnosis and pre-referral antibiotics, strengthening IMNCI training, establishing skill labs, and utilizing job aids and mentors. New cadres of community health workers and telemedicine are being introduced, alongside a large-scale SAS program for awareness, capacity building, early diagnosis, and vaccination.
Dr. Priyanda from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation discusses the complex drivers of health worker performance, moving beyond just 'hardware' (inputs) to 'software' (training, norms, culture). She emphasizes understanding facility hierarchies, relationship dynamics, healthcare worker motivation, and community expectations. She also points out the need to invest beyond just means, looking at motives and opportunities for health workers, and suggests donors should collaboratively support governments, focusing on social entrepreneurs and customized approaches.
Dr. Anna Ditchin from UNICEF discusses the global organization's role in addressing misdiagnosis. She advocates for utilizing existing evidence to strengthen health systems, institutionalizing performance monitoring, collecting local data, and empowering health workers. UNICEF supports integrating pediatric quality of care comprehensively across all service levels, engaging private providers, and moving beyond traditional training to mentorship, digital tools, and operational research. She highlights pulse oximetry as a key diagnostic tool and views pneumonia as a tracer for primary healthcare functionality, calling for renewed global focus through the child health task force.
The panelists engage in a rapid-fire discussion about the continued relevance of IMCI. There's a consensus that IMCI as a core programming tool is still valid, but its implementation needs to be strengthened, focusing on systemic issues, health system strengthening, and adapting to diverse contexts. The need for comprehensive approaches that integrate various aspects of care, community engagement, and strong partnerships is emphasized.
Dr. Rajiv Tandon provides closing remarks, thanking the presenters and panelists for their insightful contributions. He reiterates the timeliness of the discussion given upcoming global focus on childhood pneumonia. He highlights the agreement on the need for more and better action, emphasizing partnerships and understanding 'how' interventions are implemented, not just 'what' to do. He acknowledges the systemic challenges and the diverse perspectives shared, looking forward to continued engagement and work towards reducing childhood pneumonia mortality.