HF Antenna Battle: Chameleon vs. Radioddity vs. JPC-12

Share

Summary

This video compares three popular, center-mounted, coil-loaded vertical HF antennas: the Radioddity, JPC-12, and Chameleon antennas. The review covers their adjustment mechanisms, design, included accessories, physical dimensions, whip characteristics, and ultimately their price points, highlighting the pros and cons of each for portable ham radio operation.

Highlights

Chameleon Antenna Configuration Options and Accessories
00:03:25

The Chameleon antenna is highly configurable, allowing the coil to be mounted at various heights. It comes with a comprehensive kit including extension poles, a ground spike, a tripod adapter, a radial connecting plate, radials, a table clamp, and RG58 coax, all neatly packed in an EVA case.

Introduction to Coil Loaded Vertical Antennas
00:00:00

The video introduces a comparison of three coil-loaded vertical antennas: Radioddity, JPC-12, and Chameleon. All are center-mounted and vary significantly in price and quality.

Radioddity Antenna Coil & Adjustment
00:00:16

The Radioddity antenna features a coil at the top of the pole with an internal adjustment mechanism that slides up and down. The contact makes an audible sound when adjusted.

JPC-12 Antenna Coil & Adjustment
00:00:42

The JPC-12 antenna has an exposed coil mechanism that is adjusted by sliding a slider up and down. Unlike some other designs, it only offers discrete taps rather than continuous fine-tuning like Buddy Pole or Wolf River coils.

Chameleon Antenna Coil & Adjustment
00:01:43

The Chameleon antenna uses a Delrin-based coil with external windings. Its adjustment involves a springy attachment point and a plastic knob to secure the slider, offering a robust but non-rotational adjustment.

Radioddity Antenna Components and Compatibility
00:05:35

The Radioddity kit includes three sets of radials, a BNC to SO239 adapter, unnamed coax (likely RG58), a whip, two extension poles, the coil (acting as another extension), and a unique ground spike with male threads, making it less compatible with standard 3/8-24 accessories without adapters.

JPC-12 Antenna Components and Tuning
00:06:48

The JPC-12 comes with ribbon cable radials, a base adapter, four extension poles, a ground spike, and a whip. The coil tap has clear markings for 20m and 40m, and fine-tuning is achieved by adjusting the whip's height.

Antenna Height Comparison
00:08:50

A side-by-side comparison reveals the Chameleon antenna stands at 9 feet, the Radioddity at 12 feet 9 inches, and the JPC-12 at 14 feet 3 inches. The Chameleon's coil design allows for additional height extension.

Whip Design and Durability
00:09:34

Chameleon whips are known for their thick top sections and an internal crimp to prevent over-extension. Radioddity whips also feature thick sections and double crimps for added security. The JPC-12 whip is notably thinner at the top and lacks the extra crimp, though it appears sturdy.

Coax and Connector Standardisation
00:11:50

The JPC-12 is the only antenna without included coax. All three antennas use SO239 connectors on the antenna side, and the included coaxes (where applicable) have PL259 connectors.

Factors for Choosing an Antenna and Pricing
00:12:05

Key factors for selection include perceived quality, affordability, portability, and deployment speed (all deployable within 5 minutes). The JPC-12 costs about $150, the Radioddity about $200, and the Chameleon MCC kit ranges from $350 to $674 depending on the specific kit (POTA, SOTA, or limited edition).

Recently Summarized Articles

Loading...