Passbolt - Why I Can't Recommend This Password Manager

Share

Summary

The creator discusses a Bitwarden vulnerability involving iframe autofill, then details their experience with Passbolt, highlighting privacy and usability concerns such as user visibility, mandatory browser extensions, PGP key requirements for login, and global email notifications.

Highlights

Introduction and Bitwarden Vulnerability00:00:00

The speaker emphasizes the importance of password managers and discusses a vulnerability found by Flashpoint in Bitwarden regarding the autofill of credentials in embedded iframes across different domains.

Introduction to Passbolt00:01:45

After seeing content about Passbolt, the speaker decided to test it for a month. They found the Docker setup process simple but have reservations about recommending it for average self-hosters.

Privacy and User Visibility Issues00:02:55

A major concern is that all users on a server can see other user accounts, their last login times, and when they updated their vault, which the speaker finds unnecessary for password sharing.

Browser Extension and PGP Requirements00:03:55

Passbolt requires a browser extension to access the web app and mandates a PGP file for password recovery or signing in on new browsers, which is not user-friendly for average users.

Passphrase Management and Mobile Experience00:05:36

The passphrase is stored locally per device, meaning changes do not sync across browsers. However, the mobile experience is noted as better, allowing multiple accounts without PGP keys and offering fingerprint authentication.

Two-Factor Authentication and Email Settings00:06:39

Passbolt supports TOTP, YubiKey, and Duo for 2FA. However, default email notifications are global and cannot be disabled by individual users, leading to excessive emails during password imports.

Conclusion and Target Audience00:09:07

The speaker concludes that Passbolt is designed for organizations like Fortune 500 companies and universities that prioritize privacy, rather than for users easily frustrated by technology.

Recently Summarized Articles

Loading...
Summarize another YouTube video →