I Backtested 7 Day Trading Strategies on 8 Years of Data. 1 Survived

Share

Summary

A comprehensive backtest of seven popular day trading strategies using 8 years of real Nasdaq data, revealing that only one strategy remained positive after costs, but with significant drawdown and reliance on a single outlier trade.

Highlights

Introduction and Test Methodology00:00:00

The video tests seven popular day trading strategies on 8 years of Nasdaq data, with every rule and cost included. The methodology uses 2,186 full Nasdaq sessions in 1-minute candles, split into a study period (2018-2022) and a control period (2023-2026) to ensure strategies work on unseen data. All trades include spread and slippage costs, with stop and target hits in the same minute counted as losses. Results are measured in R (risk per trade).

Strategies 1-4: Consistent Losers00:01:01

Strategy 1 (Liquidity Sweep): Price sweeps yesterday's high/low and reverses; 633 trades, study period -0.10R, control -0.12R. Verdict: noise. Strategy 2 (80% Rule): Market opens outside yesterday's value area and returns; 466 trades, study -0.03R, control -0.17R. Verdict: noise, worsened on new data. Strategy 3 (Gap Fade): Small opening gap traded back to previous close; only 50 trades due to strict filters, study -0.14R, control -0.26R. Verdict: noise with too few trades. Strategy 4 (Last Half-Hour Momentum): Follow daily direction at 3:30 PM into close; over 2,000 trades, study -0.01R, control -0.08R. Verdict: noise, with a drawdown of over 120R.

Strategies 5-6: Trap and Coin Flip00:02:49

Strategy 5 (Initial Balance Breakout): Trade first 5-minute close outside first hour's range; 1,779 trades, study +0.05R, control -0.03R. Verdict: a trap as it only worked in the study period. Strategy 6 (15-Minute Opening Range Breakout): First 5-minute close outside first 15 minutes, stop at middle, 2R target; 2,107 trades, study +0.01R, control +0.02R. Verdict: basically a coin flip after costs.

Strategy 7: The Survivor00:03:47

Strategy 7 (Opening Range Breakout with VWAP Exit): Same as Strategy 6 but managed with VWAP; 1,523 trades, study +0.058R, control +0.05R. The only strategy positive in both periods. The key change is the exit method, using VWAP to determine when to exit. Example trade on July 12, 2024, gained +3R, but most days result in -1R as the strategy wins only 18% of the time.

Detailed Trade Examples00:04:17

Two trade examples illustrate the strategy: On July 12, 2024, after marking the first 15-minute range and entering on a 5-minute close outside, the stop was moved to break-even after 1R, and exit occurred on a 5-minute close below VWAP, resulting in +3R. On January 4, 2024, a similar setup hit the stop for -1R. The strategy's low win rate means many losing trades occur.

Performance Analysis and Caveats00:05:16

Over 8 years, the strategy was positive in 6 out of 9 years and in 7 out of 8 neighboring parameter settings, showing robustness. However, it suffered a 41R drawdown, equating to over $6,000 under water with $150 risk per trade. A single trade on October 10, 2025, made almost 28R; removing it drops the control period from +0.05R to near zero. The edge is thin and not statistically significant alone. On a $50K prop firm account with $2,000 trailing drawdown, the 41R drawdown cannot be absorbed. Average performance is about 0.75R per month with less than half of months profitable.

Conclusion and Lessons00:06:33

Key lessons from 8 years of data: 1. Most popular setups do not survive real costs. 2. Always test on unseen data. 3. A positive backtest is not enough; check drawdown and reliance on outlier days. 4. Test one system at a time to learn what works. The video ends with a call to action for suggestions on the next strategy to test and a disclaimer that this is not financial advice.

Recently Summarized Articles

Loading...
Summarize another YouTube video →