Summary
Highlights
Joe, a dedicated principal, is excited about her promotion, but her life takes an unexpected turn when Simon, the son of her high school ex-husband Ryan, starts at her school. Their initial interactions are tense, bringing up unresolved feelings and their secret teenage marriage, which technically was never annulled.
Joe confides in her friends about her past with Ryan, revealing their impulsive high school marriage and subsequent annulment. Her friends encourage her to confront her emotions, especially as her current boyfriend, Kareem, is considering proposing. Meanwhile, Ryan struggles with his son Simon's adjustment to the new school and his ex-wife Haley's frequent business trips.
Ryan and Joe discuss their past, with Ryan expressing regret over their rapid separation. The conversation heats up as they revisit the reasons for their split. Amidst this, Kareem proposes to Joe, and she accepts, believing he represents a calm and stable future, a stark contrast to her fiery past with Ryan.
As Joe goes to get her marriage license with Kareem, she discovers she is still legally married to Ryan, as their high school annulment was never processed. This shocking revelation forces both Joe and Kareem to confront the unexpected reality of her past.
Joe and Ryan meet at their old high school to deal with the annulment paperwork. They reminisce about their time together, including a memorable moment after a championship win. During a heated argument about their past, Ryan confesses he knew they were still married and did not pursue annulment, hoping it would bring them back together.
Ryan's confession about their marriage stuns Joe, leading to another argument. Simon's mom, Haley, returns, making Joe decide to end things with Kareem, as she acknowledges her conflicting emotions. Her friends support her decision to prioritize her heart over practicality.
After breaking off her engagement with Kareem, Joe is convinced by her friends to confront Ryan honestly. Simon, overhearing their conversation, demands they work out their differences. Ryan confesses his enduring love for Joe, and they decide to give their relationship another chance, embracing their complicated history and strong connection.