Summary
Highlights
Super Mario enters a castle, searching for Princess Peach and Bowser. Instead of Bowser, he hears a laugh and finds the Annoying Orange, who claims to be an orange and not a toad.
Mario questions Orange about the princess and Toad. Orange responds with a pun, calling Toad a 'fun-guy,' which irritates Mario, who challenges him to a fight.
Orange claims to be hungry, and Mario offers a 'spicy meatball.' Orange mocks it, calling them 'boogers.' Mario reveals his name as Super Mario, but Orange consistently mishears it as 'SpaghettiOs' and makes more jokes, further annoying Mario.
Mario becomes increasingly frustrated with Orange's jokes and mispronunciations, threatening to take off his gloves. Orange continues with pasta-related puns about Mario's family, pushing Mario to demand the princess's location.
Orange makes a 'turtle shell' joke and burps, somehow shrinking Mario and calling him 'bite-sized.' Mario laments his predicament, but Orange reveals that he already 'defeated' Bowser and saved Peach and Toad hours ago, much to Mario's surprise.
Orange boasts about defeating Bowser, but Peach clarifies that Orange merely annoyed Bowser until he left. Orange then misidentifies Peach as an 'apple,' leading to further exasperation from Peach and Toad, while Bowser complains about the freeloaders.